Which size would you use (4 or 5)?
4 years ago
My daughter is currently in the size 4 in the chest, with extra length added on top (she’s petite, but long-waisted), but a smaller size on pants (size 2)
In the case of tops/dresses, most only go through size 4, then buy the next package for size 5+.
So…if she’s currently a 4, do I stick with the smaller size for now? Or is the 5 not *too* much bigger, that I might be able to get away with that one? I simply hate to invest so much when it’s the last size (then again, I have no idea when she’ll grow again)4 years ago
Hmmm…re-reading, that didn’t make sense…
I was asking which size patterns to BUY (not use), if buying a new one! Buy the package size that goes UP to 4? Or buy the pattern size that begins at 5?4 years agoSarvi @Sarvi
Hm, that’s a bit tricky. I think I’d buy the smaller range for patterns that include bottoms, as it would be pretty tricky to narrow and shorten from 5 to 2, but get the larger range for dress-only or coat patterns. Do you have a sense of how much longer she’ll be in the 4s? Has she just recently grown into them, or been wearing 4s for a while and might be due to grow again soon? Mine is in a weird in betweenish stage too, less because of measurements than because of proportions, so right now I’m making 5s and living with a bit of roominess in certain things.4 years agoroundtheworldgirl @roundtheworldgirl
I am in the same boat as you! My older girl is actually the length of a 6 but she is still a 2, 3 or 4 in width depending on the pattern. I mostly have the smaller ranges for now although I did buy the larger Playtime recently since she now takes a 4 width for the leggings and I am guessing that 5 won’t be that far off. I am thinking that when she gets taller I will need access to both size ranges when I am drafting for her, since I often need to consult the larger size for things like pant rise or underarm curve. So I guess it depends on the pattern. The Ice Cream dress, for example, is one that is fairly straightforward to lengthen and that I know the bodice size will cover me for a long time. But for the After-School Pants with the back yoke, I’d need both sizes in front of me. Does that make sense?
4 years agomeleliza @meleliza
- This reply was modified 4 years ago by roundtheworldgirl.
How old is your daughter? Because they grow more slowly as they get older. I’m thinking if you have a long wait, just get the smaller ones you really love now.
I’ve recently adapted an old fashioned clothes policy: buy (or sew) quality and make it last. I’m buying 5 (and making) for my 4 1\2 year old, though she can still fit some size 4 dresses. However, I also made her some size 6 dresses because she needed long sleeved, but only for a little longer. I just roll up the sleeves until she’s a little taller. They’re roomy, but it’s fine for play clothes. I wouldn’t do this for a special occasion.4 years agoCat75 @Cat75
I would buy the larger size. Unless you plan to make something right now, like an Easter dress or something special. I just can’t justify spending money on something I might not get around to using.4 years agokgiff @kgiff
I decided to just buy the larger sizes. I’ve been patiently waiting to make a few for over a year. But I just couldn’t justify buying the smaller size when chances were I’d only get around to making it once.
I did buy a couple smaller ones with the last sale though…4 years ago
Thanks, y’all. I just measured and she’s a 2 for pants and a spot-on 4 for tops. Perhaps sticking with 4s for now, and sewing slightly narrower seam allowances as she grows will be best. With that big of a span between pants and tops, buying size 5+ for patterns with tops/pants would be useless!4 years agoNicole @motherof5
I agree Rebecca
My 6 year old measures a 2!4 years agoJess M. @mommy2maria
I’m having this issue right now! I usually scale up. Only because I know we will wear it eventually! This said, I haven’t made many of the pants yet! Only shorts!
I have the feeling Maria is teeny like Tildy! I think the ones I know are a tight fit over the head, I’m sizing up to 5’s. I’m still debating on the Family Reunion–4 or 5 LOL. I might just make the 4 because it’s the pattern I have. Now I’m second guessing cutting the 4/5 of the puppet show shorts!
Is applepicking supposed to be on the slim side?
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Unless otherwise credited, all work on this blog is © Liesl + Co., Inc, 2008-2019. You are welcome to link to this blog, but please ask permission before using any text or images.