Sleeve trouble

I wondered if someone could take a look at my pictures and tell me what you think is wrong with my sleeves? This is my first time making this pattern with the long sleeve option, and something just looks wrong, almost like they are twisted. My sleeve pattern piece seems to be perfectly symmetrical, and there are no notches designating front and back on either the sleeve or bodice pieces. At first I thought maybe I attached them wrong, but I don't see how I could have. The fabric is a 100% cotton jersey that I repurposed from a XXL tshirt I bought off the rack because I loved the color. I was really careful to make sure I cut with the correct grainline. Thanks in advance for any thoughts you may have. I'm thinking right now I'll just take the sleeves off and add the sleeve cuff option instead, but still wanted to figure out the problem :)